Home-->m-comment-000-eng-->mb-comment-008-81-eng
PC

Broxton Comment-MB-008-81

FA6912 Sai cosa faceva Stalin alle donne? / What Did Stalin Do to Women?
Auther: Jonathan Broxton

ENNIO MORRICONE REVIEWS, Part 8-81

SAI COSA FACEVA STALIN ALLE DONNE? (1969)

Sai Cosa Faceva Stalin Alle Donne? – which roughly translates as What Did Stalin Do To Women – is an Italian comedy drama with a political undertone, written and directed by Maurizio Liverani. The story focus on Aldo and Benedetto (Helmut Berger and Benedetto Benedetti), two young and idealistic Communist intellectuals who come to Rome under the patronage of an important left-wing politician. Benedetto is serious, and involves himself in political activities, but Aldo becomes quickly disillusioned with his new life, and exploits his coincidental physical resemblance to Stalin as a means to woo women.

Morricone’s score for the film is basically a series of variations on two central main theme, one unsurprisingly called “Lo Sai Cosa Faceva Stalin Alle Donne?” and the other called “Lo Sai Che Cosa Facevano Le Donne a Stalin?”. “Lo Sai Cosa Faceva Stalin Alle Donne?” has a slightly comedic air, with quirky vocals and a peculiar tuba melody that eventually picks up a spiky, glittery arrangement that includes strings, harpsichord, piano, electric bass guitar, accordion, and tapped wooden percussion. The whole thing has an idiosyncratic, caper-like feel that is amusing and fun, that I like quite a great deal. Later, there is a more groovy lounge music arrangement (#2), a Europop/rock version (#5), and a truly bizarre version that breaks down the theme entirely and surrounds it with breathing and noises and the sound of someone scraping a wet finger down a window (#4).

On the other hand, “Lo Sai Che Cosa Facevano Le Donne a Stalin?” is grittier, dirtier, and jazzier, with a terrific muted trumpet solo (#1), a tango variation (#2), a variation with wordless vocals (#3), and even a liturgical chant that sounds like medieval plainsong (#4)! Meanwhile, the “Scherzo da Guerra” is a piece of frothy renaissance-inflected dance fluff with a prominent organ, lively strings, and a soft rock beat, while “Filastrocca Per Cretini” is a near-indescribable piece which moves from something approximating a medieval jester’s march to a fun bossa nova beat, before ending with more of those ‘fingers-on-windows’ noises, kisses, and orgasm noises. Only Morricone!

There had been a couple of releases of the score for Sai Cosa Faceva Stalin Alle Donne by Italian label CAM, which usually paired it with music from the 1980 film Stark System. It was finally released as a standalone album in 2013 by Beat Records, and this is the one I’ve reviewed here. It’s a fun score, offbeat and creative, but of its more out-there moments might strike some people are being just too peculiar for words.

Track Listing: 1. Lo Sai Cosa Faceva Stalin Alle Donne? (2:23), 2. Lo Sai Che Cosa Facevano Le Donne a Stalin? (1:54), 3. Scherzo da Guerra (2:08), 4. Lo Sai Cosa Faceva Stalin Alle Donne? #2 (0:55), 5. Lo Sai Cosa Faceva Stalin Alle Donne? #3 (1:48), 6. Scherzo da Guerra #2 (1:07), 7. Lo Sai Cosa Faceva Stalin Alle Donne? #4 (4:25), 8. Scherzo da Baffone (1:18), 9. Lo Sai Cosa Faceva Stalin Alle Donne? #5 (1:18), 10. Lo Sai Cosa Faceva Stalin Alle Donne? #6 (4:36), 11. Filastrocca Per Cretini (2:43), 12. Scherzo da Guerra #3 (3:05), 13. Lo Sai Che Cosa Facevano Le Donne a Stalin? #2 (0:34), 14. Lo Sai Che Cosa Facevano Le Donne a Stalin? #3 (2:36), 15. Filastrocca Per Cretini #2 (1:19), 16. Lo Sai Che Cosa Facevano Le Donne a Stalin? #4 (0:57), 17. Lo Sai Che Cosa Facevano Le Donne a Stalin? #5 (2:24). Beat Records BCM-9524, 35 minutes 30 seconds

Oct. 17, 2020
Film Appreciation on This Website
Online music audition
001
Lo sai cosa faceva Stalin alle donne ? (04:37)
002
Scherzo da guerra (03:04)
003
Scherzo da baffone (01:19)
004
Lo sai cosa facevano le donne a Stalin ? (01:55)
005
Filastrocca per cretini (02:44)
Attachment: About Jonathan Broxton
Jon is a film music critic and journalist, who since 1997 has been the editor and chief reviewer for Movie Music UK, one of the world’s most popular English-language film music websites, and is the president of the International Film Music Critics Association (IFMCA). Over the last 20+ years Jon has written over 3,000 reviews and articles and conducted numerous composer interviews. In print, Jon has written reviews and articles for publications such as Film Score Monthly, Soundtrack Magazine and Music from the Movies, and has written liner notes for two of Prometheus Records’ classic Basil Poledouris score releases, “Amanda” and “Flyers/Fire on the Mountain”. He also contributed a chapter to Tom Hoover’s book “Soundtrack Nation: Interviews with Today’s Top Professionals in Film, Videogame, and Television Scoring”, published in 2011. In the late 1990s Jon was a film music consultant to the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra in London, and worked with them on the films “Relative Values” with music by John Debney, and “The Ring of the Buddha” with music by Oliver Heise, as well as on a series of concerts with Randy Newman. In 2012, Jon chaired one of the “festival academies” at the 5th Annual Film Music Festival in Krakow, Poland. He is a member of the Society of Composers and Lyricists, the premier nonprofit organization for composers, lyricists, and songwriters working motion pictures, television, and multimedia. (Here)
2023.12.10
2023 Mobile version

VIP

Philately The site standby Collection transfer
Started running in 2003. The site http://morricone.cn standby http://em.hty66.com 信息产业部备案序号(2014): 苏ICP备11039856号 © 2015 hwg 版权所有